Equity options
How you pay for home equity: interest, fees or a share of future value
Home equity is the part of a house you own outright. Several kinds of arrangement let a homeowner turn some of it into cash. They differ most in what they charge and when. One adds interest month by month. One adds a single fixed payment schedule. One replaces the first mortgage. One asks for no monthly payment at all and takes a share of the home's later value instead. This guide sets the four side by side and lists what to ask before you commit to any of them.
In this guide
One question sorts the optionsA line of credit: pay for what you useA fixed home equity loan: one sum, one scheduleA cash-out refinance: a new first mortgageA shared-equity arrangement: pay with future valueCompare when the cost arrivesAsk about every fee, not just the rateWhat to ask before committingKey takeaways
- Each way of using equity charges for the money differently: interest, fees, or a share of future value.
- Monthly payments and total cost are two separate things, and an option can be easy on one and heavy on the other.
- A shared-equity arrangement has no interest rate, but its cost depends on what the home is worth later.
- Written answers to the same questions, asked of each provider, make the options comparable.
One question sorts the options
People often start by asking which option has the better price. A sharper first question is how each option charges and when. Money from home equity is never free to use. The cost simply takes different shapes.
Three of the four options charge interest, which is a percentage of what you owe, added over time. They differ in how the balance and the rate behave. The fourth option, shared equity, charges a part of the home's value. Keep that split in mind, because it changes what you compare.
A line of credit: pay for what you use
A home equity line of credit sets a limit and lets you borrow in pieces, repay, and borrow again during a set period. You owe interest only on the part you have drawn. Many lines carry a rate that moves with a published index, so the monthly figure can change.
The cost arrives gradually and follows your own use. A line you never draw on charges little or nothing in interest, though some agreements add yearly or setup fees. The open question is the end of the borrowing period, when the line turns into a repayment schedule.
A fixed home equity loan: one sum, one schedule
A home equity loan pays you the full amount at once. You then repay it in equal installments over a stated number of years, usually at a rate that stays put. Because the schedule is set on day one, you can see the whole path of payments before you sign.
You pay interest on the entire sum from the first day, whether or not you have spent it. In exchange, you get a payment that does not move. The loan sits beside your first mortgage as a second debt on the house.
A cash-out refinance: a new first mortgage
A cash-out refinance does not add a second debt. It replaces the first mortgage with a larger one and pays you the difference. Everything about the old mortgage is reset: the rate, the term and the closing costs.
This option charges in two places. The interest applies to the whole new balance, not only the cash you took out. The closing costs apply to the whole new loan as well. Ask what the old mortgage's terms were, because you give them up.
A shared-equity arrangement: pay with future value
In a shared-equity arrangement, an investor gives you a sum of money now. You make no monthly payment on it. In return, the investor receives a stated share of the home's value when the arrangement ends, which may happen on a sale or at a set date.
There is no interest rate to read, so the usual comparison tools do not apply. The cost depends on two things nobody can know today: what the home will be worth, and how long the arrangement lasts. If the value rises a lot, the share can be large. If it falls, the share can be smaller than the sum you received.
Compare when the cost arrives
Set the four options on a timeline. A line charges a little at first, then more as you borrow and as the rate moves. A fixed loan charges the same each month until it ends. A refinance charges a new mortgage payment for a long time. A shared-equity arrangement charges nothing monthly, then a large amount at the end.
Neither shape is better by itself. An option that is gentle each month can be heavy in total. An option with no monthly payment can leave a large bill on the day it ends. Match the shape to when you expect to have money available.
Ask about every fee, not just the rate
Fees show up under different names. For each option, ask for a written list that covers these items:
- an origination fee, which pays for setting up the loan or arrangement;
- an appraisal, which is a professional estimate of the home's value;
- title and recording charges;
- any yearly fee, and any charge for ending early;
- for shared equity, whether setup fees are paid up front or deducted from the sum you receive.
A fee taken out of the sum means you receive less than the headline figure, yet the share or the interest still applies to the full amount.
What to ask before committing
- How does this option charge me, and when does each charge arrive?
- What is the total I would owe or give up in a calm case, and in a case where the home value moves sharply?
- What happens if I want to sell, refinance or end the arrangement early?
- Is anything about the terms allowed to change after I sign?
- What does the agreement say if I miss a payment or cannot meet a condition?
- Who else must sign, and what is recorded against the house?
Ask each provider the same questions and keep the answers in writing. Rules on these products vary by state, so check the terms of your own agreement and ask an independent professional to explain any part that is unclear.
Why we wrote this. Two options can hand over the same sum and still cost very different amounts, because one charges month by month and another charges at the end. This page sets out the usual patterns; the written terms of any real agreement decide what applies to it.